0001
 1       IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF DELAWARE
 2         IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
 3                    -  -  -
 4   JANINE ARUANNO       : CIVIL ACTION
                          :
 5          v.            :
                          :
 6   CHRISTINE WILLEY,    :
     2009 L.L.C., t/d/b/a :
 7   THE STARBOARD        :
     RESTAURANT AND BAR;  :
 8   J-RAE, INC. t/d/b/a  :
     RESORT INVESTIGATIONS:
 9   AND PATROL and       :
     JANET KANSACK        : NO. 04C-05-267-MMJ
10   
                      -  -  -
11   
                  APRIL 30, 2007
12   
                      -  -  -
13   
14                Oral videotape deposition of
     MATTHEW J. NAGORSKY, M.D., taken pursuant
15   to notice, was held at the offices of
     UNIVERSITY OTOLARYNGOLOGY ASSOCIATES,
16   P.C., 205 North Broad Street, Suite 401,
     Philadelphia, Pennsylvania beginning at
17   6:19 p.m., on the above date, before
     Dottyann Y. Walsh, a Certified Shorthand
18   Reporter and Notary Public in the
     Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
19   
                      -  -  -
20   
21   
22          ESQUIRE DEPOSITION SERVICES
                    Suite 1210
23        1600 John F. Kennedy Boulevard
         Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103
24                (215) 988-9191
0002
 1   APPEARANCES:
 2   
            STEIN & TROIANI, P.C.
 3          BY:  MICHAEL J. TROIANI, ESQUIRE
            166 East Levering Mill Road
 4          Suite 205
            Bala Cynwyd, Pennsylvania 19004
 5          (610) 660-8700
            Representing the Plaintiff
 6   
 7          RAWLE & HENDERSON, LLP
            BY:  WILLIAM J. CATTIE III,
 8               ESQUIRE
            300 Delaware Avenue
 9          Suite 1015
            Wilmington, Delaware 19801
10          (302) 778-1200
            Representing the Defendant
11          Resort Investigations and
            Janet Kansack
12   
13          WILSON HALBROOK & BAYARD
            BY:  ERIC C. HOWARD, ESQUIRE
14          107 West Market Street
            Georgetown, Delaware 19947
15          (302) 856-0015
            Representing the Defendant
16          2009 L.L.C.
17   
18          ALSO PRESENT:  Larry Simon
                           Videographer
19   
                     -  -  -
20   
21   
22   
23   
24   
0003
 1                    -  -  -
 2                   I N D E X
 3                    -  -  -
 4   Testimony of:  MATTHEW J. NAGORSKY, M.D.
 5   
        By Mr. Troiani                 6,49
 6   
        By Mr. Cattie                    34
 7   
        By Mr. Howard                    45
 8   
 9   
                      -  -  -
10   
                  E X H I B I T S
11   
                      -  -  -
12   
     NO.        DESCRIPTION             PAGE
13   
     P-3        Curriculum Vitae           5
14   
         (EXHIBIT RETAINED BY MR. TROIANI)
15   
16   
17   
18   
19   
20   
21   
22   
23   
24   
0004
 1                    -  -  -
 2           DEPOSITION SUPPORT INDEX
 3                    -  -  -
 4   
 5   Direction to Witness Not to Answer
 6   Page Line      Page Line       Page Line
 7   None
 8   
 9   
10   Request for Production of Documents
11   Page Line      Page Line       Page Line
12   None
13   
14   
15   Stipulations
16   Page Line      Page Line       Page Line
17   None
18   
19   
20   Question Marked
21   Page Line      Page Line       Page Line
22   None
23   
24   
0005
 1                     - - -
 2              DIRECT EXAMINATION
 3                     - - -
 4                (Exhibit P-3 marked for
 5          identification.)
 6                THE VIDEOGRAPHER:  We are
 7          now on the record.  My name is
 8          Larry Simon.  I'm the video
 9          technician employed by Esquire
10          Deposition Services, 1600 JFK
11          Boulevard, Suite 1210,
12          Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
13                This is the video deposition
14          in the Superior Court of the State
15          of Delaware In and For New Castle
16          County.  CA No. 04C-05-267-MMJ.
17          This dep is being held at 205
18          North Broad Street, Philadelphia,
19          Pennsylvania in the matter of
20          Janine Aruanno versus Christine
21          Willey, et al.  The deponent is
22          Matthew Nagorsky, MD.  This
23          deposition is taken on behalf of
24          the plaintiff.
0006
 1                All counsel will be noted on
 2          the stenographic record.  The
 3          court reporter is Dotty Walsh and
 4          she will now swear in the witness.
 5                    -  -  -
 6                MATTHEW J. NAGORSKY, M.D.
 7          after having been duly sworn, was
 8          examined and testified as follows:
 9                   -  -  -
10   BY MR. TROIANI:
11          Q.    Dr. Nagorsky, would you
12   p