1


           1          IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS

           2          LEHIGH COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA

           3                     - - -

           4   JULIA A. BOGERT,        :2002-C-326V

           5   administratrix of the   : 

           6   Estate of EDWIN BOGERT  :

           7   Deceased, et al.        :

           8          Vs.              :

           9   LEHIGH VALLEY HOSPITAL, :

          10   Et al.                  :

          11                     - - -
                            Videotape deposition of 
          12   David S. Brody, M.D., taken pursuant to 
               Notice, held at the offices of 
          13   David S. Brody, M.D., Drexel 
               University College of Medicine, 245 North 
          14   15th Street, Philadelphia, PA, on Friday, 
               February 27, 2004, at 5:40 p.m., before 
          15   John W. Begley, a Federally Approved 
               Registered Professional Reporter - Notary 
          16   Public in and for the Commonwealth of 
               Pennsylvania.
          17                     - - -

          18          ESQUIRE DEPOSITION SERVICES

          19                 15th Floor   

          20         1880 John F. Kennedy Boulevard

          21        Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103

          22                 215 - 988-9191

          23                        

          24                        







                                                       2


           1   A P P E A R A N C E S:  

           2   SALTZ, MONGELUZZI, BARRETT & BENDESKY, PC

           3   BY:  ARA RICHARD AVRIGIAN, ESQUIRE

           4   One Liberty Place - 34th Floor

           5   1650 Market Street

           6   Philadelphia, PA  19103

           7   Phone:  215 - 575-2971

           8   Representing the Plaintiffs

           9   

          10   WEBER, GALLAGHER, SIMPSON, STAPLETON,

          11   FIRES & NEWBY, LLP

          12   BY:  EUGENE P. FEENEY, ESQUIRE

          13   321 Spruce street

          14   Bank Towers Building

          15   Scranton, PA  18503

          16   Phone:  570 - 961-2120

          17   Representing the Defendant

          18   Edward J. Rosenfeld, M.D.

          19   

          20   

          21   

          22   

          23   

          24   







                                                       3


           1   LAW OFFICES OF KEVIN WRIGHT

           2   BY:  MARK ZOLFAGHARI, ESQUIRE

           3   446 North Lane

           4   Conshohocken, PA  19465

           5   Representing the Defendant 

           6   James Edwards Redenbaugh, M.D.

           7   

           8   LAW OFFICES KILCOYNE & ASSOCIATES

           9   BY:  GREGORY S. NESBITT, ESQUIRE

          10   2250 Hickory Road - Suite 216

          11   Plymouth Meeting, PA  19462

          12   Phone:  610 - 825-2833

          13   Representing the Defendant 

          14   Lisa N. Gray, D.O.

          15   

          16   ALSO PRESENT:  Edward Caswell, IV

          17          

          18   

          19   

          20   

          21   

          22   

          23   

          24   







                                                       4


           1                     - - -

           2                 I  N  D  E  X

           3                     - - -

           4   Testimony of David S. Brody, M.D.  PAGE

           5   By Mr. Nesbitt             8, 24, 111 

           6   By Mr. Avrigian            20, 60, 120

           7   By Mr. Zolfaghari                  104

           8   By Mr. Feeney                      128

           9                     - - -

          10                E X H I B I T S

          11                      - - -                 

          12   EXHIBIT      DESCRIPTION           PAGE    

          13   Gray 1       Curriculum of           6

          14                David S. Brody, M.D.

          15   Gray 2       Letter to Gregory       6  

          16                Nesbitt from David

          17                Brody, M.D. dated

          18                2/18/04

          19   

          20   

          21   

          22   

          23   

          24   







                                                       5


           1            DEPOSITION SUPPORT INDEX

           2   Objections to questions 

           3   Page   Line       Page  Line 

           4   46     11

           5   72      4

           6   76     15

           7   94      8

           8   100    13

           9   109    15         

          10   Request For Production of Documents

          11   Page   Li