1


                           IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS

                                COUNTY OF MAHONING





                 SALLY A. GRACE, et al.,

                             Plaintiffs,              Case No.

                      V.                              98CV0248

                                                    MONSANTO

                 COMPANY, et al.,

                             Defendants.





                             Deposition of DAVID M. ROSENBERG,

                 M.D., called for examination under the statute,

                 taken before me, Renee L. Pellegrino, Registered

                 Professional Reporter in and for the State of

                 Ohio, by agreement of counsel, at the offices of

                 David M. Rosenburg, M.D., 3909 Orange Avenue,

                 Beachwood, Ohio, on Thursday, May 16, 2002, at

                 5:00 p.m.

                                     - - - - -

                                                                  2


                 APPEARANCES:



                       On behalf of the Plaintiffs:

                             Perantinides & Nolan, by

                             PETER D. JANOS, ESQ.

                             300 Courtyard Square

                             80 South Summit Street

                             Akron, Ohio  44308

                             (330) 253-5454



                       On behalf of Defendant O.M. Scott &

                       Sons Co.:

                             Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease, by

                             MARCEL C. DUHAMEL, ESQ.

                             2100 One Cleveland Center

                             1375 East Ninth Street

                             Cleveland, Ohio  44114-1724

                             (216) 479-6100

                                        3


            1    APPEARANCES, Continued:

            2

            3          On behalf of Defendants Chevron USA and

            4          Monsanto:

            5                Parker, Leiby, Hanna & Rasnick, by

            6                A. ELIZABETH CARGLE, ESQ.

            7                2100 One Cascade Plaza

            8                Akron, Ohio  44308

            9                (330) 253-2227

           10                        - - - -

           11