1
 1   IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
    STARK COUNTY, OHIO
 2   
    Case No 2003 CVO 0212
 3   
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
 4   DEPOSITION OF ALVIN J SCHONFELD, DO
 5   
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
    ALBERT DUCKWORTH,
 6   
    Plaintiff,
 7   
    v
 8   
    THE TIMKEN COMPANY, et al,
 9   
    Defendants
10   
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
           The deposition of ALVIN J SCHONFELD, DO was
11   taken by the Plaintiff on June 10, 2003, at the Park
    Hyatt Beaver Creek Resort and Spa, 136 East Thomas
12   Place, Beaver Creek, Colorado commencing at the hour of
    9:32 am, before ROSANNE M STAHL, Certified Shorthand
13   Reporter and Notary Public within and for the State of
    Colorado
14   
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
15                A P P E A R A N C E S
16   COREY W FROST, ESQ
    KELLEY & FERRARO, LLP
17   1300 East Ninth Street, Suite 1901
    Cleveland, OH  44114
18   Ph 216-575-0777
19   STEPHEN E MATASICH, ESQ
    DAY, KETTERER, RALEY, WRIGHT & RYBOT, LTD
20   Millennium Centre, Suite 300
    200 Market Avenue, North
21   PO Box 24213
    Canton, Ohio  44701-4213
22   Ph 330-445-0173
23   
24   
25   

                                                                     2
 1                            INDEX
 2   EXAMINATION BY                            PAGES
 3   MR FROST (CREDENTIALS)                   4 - 21
    MR FROST                                 21 - 38
 4   MR MATASICH                              38 - 61
    MR FROST                                 61 - 68
 5   MR MATASICH                              68 - 69
 6   -----------------------------------------------------------
    REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE                    70
 7   
    DEPONENT'S SIGNATURE PAGE and
 8     CORRECTION SHEET ADDENDUM               WAIVED
    -----------------------------------------------------------
 9                           EXHIBITS
10   DEPOSITION  INITIAL
    EXHIBIT     REFERENCE      BRIEF DESCRIPTION
11   
    4           36             01/24/00, B READ REPORT FOR
12                              ALBERT DUCKWORTH BY DR
                               SCHONFELD
13   
    5           26             07/16/02 SPIROMETRY TEST
14                              FOR ALBERT DUCKWORTH
15   6           23             07/16/02 MEDICAL HISTORY FOR
                               ALBERT DUCKWORTH
16   
    7           27             07/16/02 WRITTEN REPORT BY
17                              DR SCHONFELD, PATIENT:
                               ALBERT DUCKWORTH
18   
    8           20             CURRICULUM VITAE OF ALVIN J
19                              SCHONFELD, DO
20   
21   
22   
23   
24   
25   

                                                                     3
 1          (The following proceedings were not recorded on
 2   the videotape at 9:32 am)
 3          MR FROST: This morning, following the conclusion
 4   of the deposition of Dr Shonfeld in Albright v Timken
 5   Company, there was a discussion between counsel in which
 6   it has been agreed, and I appreciate Mr Matasich's
 7   Cooperation in this matter, to do -- or to use the
 8   previously-recorded testimony of Dr Shonfeld in the
 9   Albright v Timken matter as it relates expressly and
10   only to his credentials and experience as a preliminary
11   or precursory to the deposition in the matter of
12   Duckworth v The Timken Company
13          That wasn't very artful, but is that it
14   essentially, Mr Matasich?
15          MR MATASICH: That's correct  And, of course,
16   our agreement is subject to our objections that were
17   noted during the course of that portion of the direct
18   examination
19          MR FROST: Very good
20          (The following excerpt of testimony of the
21   credentials of Dr Alvin Schonfeld, DO, was taken on
22   06/10/03, 7:32 am in the case of Albright v Timken,
23   2003 CVO 0216, and inserted into this transcript
24   pursuant to the above agreement)
25   

                                                                     4
 1                      ALVIN J SCHONFELD, DO,
 2   the deponent herein, having been duly sworn, was
 3   examined and testified as follows:
 4                          EXAMINATION
 5   BY MR FROST:
 6     Q   Good morning, Doctor
 7     A   Good morning
 8     Q   I don't have my voice yet  Would you introduce
 9   yourself to the jury, please?
10     A   My name is Alvin Schonfeld  I'm a physician, and
11   I specialize in diseases of the lung
12     Q   Could you tell the jury about your academic and
13   professional backgro